Plenty of Fish Review: What 4 Weeks on POF Really Showed Me
Plenty of Fish was one of the first dating sites I ever heard of, and for many people it still is “the free one”. That reputation is exactly why I wanted it as the second platform in our hands-on series: I wanted to know how much of the old POF is left, how much now costs money, and whether the complaints about fake profiles match what a new member sees today.
This Plenty of Fish review covers 28 days on one personal account, from October 13 to November 9, 2026. I spent the first two weeks on a free account and the rest on a paid subscription, used the app on my phone every day and the website on my laptop, and compared what I saw with what thousands of members say on review sites, Reddit and Quora.
My test setup
- Test period
- 28 days, October 13 – November 9, 2026
- Devices
- iPhone app + desktop browser
- What I used
- Free account for two weeks, then a 1-month paid subscription
- Profiles
- One personal test profile
Quick verdict
My overall score after 28 days. See the breakdown
Good for
- Messaging without waiting for a mutual match
- A large pool of members in most cities
- Getting a lot done before paying anything
Might not suit
- Anyone who wants a quiet, low-volume inbox
- People who don’t want to filter out spam and fake profiles
- Those who need fast, personal customer support
What Is Plenty of Fish?
Plenty of Fish, usually shortened to POF, is an online dating site and app that launched in 2003 in Vancouver, Canada. It grew famous as the big free option, and today it’s part of Match Group, the company behind several other dating brands. The POF homepage sums up its pitch in one line: a place where you can come “exactly as you are” and choose your own way of meeting people.
That choice is the core of POF. You can swipe through profiles one at a time, run a detailed search, browse by shared interests, or simply write to someone you like without waiting for them to like you back. Few dating platforms still allow that last option, and it shapes the whole experience, for better or worse.
| Platform type | Online dating site and app |
|---|---|
| Launched | 2003, now part of Match Group |
| Access | iOS and Android apps, plus a desktop website |
| Registration | Free account with core features |
| Paid features | Subscription plans that add visibility, extra filters and messaging perks |
| Support | Help Center with articles and a contact form, Safety and Security pages |
My Plenty of Fish Rating at a Glance
I score every platform on the same seven criteria, so the numbers are comparable across reviews. You can read how each one is measured on our testing methodology page.
How I Tested Plenty of Fish
From October 13 to November 9, 2026, I used one personal profile, mostly in the POF app on my iPhone and sometimes on the desktop website. For the first 14 days, I stayed on a free account to see how far it goes, then switched to a one-month paid subscription for the second half. I browsed, searched, wrote and replied every day, used the block and report tools, read the Safety and Help pages, contacted support once, and judged everything against our seven criteria.
Signing Up: Fast, With a Lot of Questions

I signed up in the app, which is where POF clearly wants you to be. The flow is quick, but it asks for more about you than most apps do, so it pays to have a few minutes free.
Step 1: The basics
Email or phone, a password, your first name, date of birth, gender, who you want to meet, and your location. Nothing here was unusual, and it took me about two minutes.
Step 2: About you
Next comes a long list of profile questions: what you’re looking for, height, education, lifestyle, and more. Many are optional, and I liked that I could skip a few and fill them in later rather than being blocked from moving on.
Step 3: Photos, bio and interests
POF asks for photos and a short “about me”. I added a clear main photo, a full-length picture, and a couple of activity shots, then picked a handful of interests. Interests turned out to matter more than I expected, because they decide where you appear when people browse by topic.
Logging in later
The POF app keeps you signed in, and on desktop you press “Sign In” in the top-right corner of pof.com and use the same email and password.
The Features That Define POF
Plenty of Fish has a lot of menus, so I focused on the features I actually used and the ones that make POF different.
Messaging without a match
This is the feature POF is known for. You can write to someone after viewing their profile, without waiting for a mutual like. It made the first days far livelier than on match-only apps, and I started more conversations myself than I usually do. The flip side is that anyone can write to you too, which I come back to in the safety section.
My take: the main reason to choose POF, and the main reason to set your filters carefully.
Meet Me
Meet Me shows one profile at a time and lets you say yes or no, a lot like swiping. When two people both say yes, POF tells you. I used it in short bursts in the evenings, and it was the quickest way to get a feel for who was active nearby.
My take: quick and familiar, but the search gave me more control.
Search and filters
The search lets you narrow results by age, distance, what people are looking for, and several other details. On the free account, the basic filters were enough; the paid plan unlocked a few more. Like some reviewers, I noticed that a few results sat slightly outside my distance setting.
My take: detailed, though not always precise.
Browsing by interests
POF lets you browse members by shared interests. I found this the most pleasant way to discover profiles, because the first message practically writes itself when you both love the same thing.
My take: an underrated feature and my favorite way to find people.
Likes, views, and “who liked me”
You can like profiles and see some of the activity on your own. Seeing the full list of who liked you and who viewed you is part of the paid plan, and it was the upgrade I found most useful.
My take: worth paying for if you’re short on time.
Free vs. Paid: How Far a Free Account Goes
Plenty of Fish still lets you do the essentials for free: create a profile, browse, search, use Meet Me, and message people. That’s a lot more than most dating platforms offer without paying.
When I switched to a paid subscription in week three, the experience didn’t change completely. It became more comfortable: I could see who had liked and viewed me and use extra filters, and my profile got more visibility. In my experience, the paid plan is about saving time rather than unlocking the platform. Plan names and prices change and vary by country, so check the current options in the app before you buy, and turn off auto-renewal if you only want one month.
Is Plenty of Fish Safe? What I Ran Into
This is the question I cared most about, because fake profiles and scams are the top complaint about POF online. Here’s what I found and what the platform gives you to deal with it.
What my inbox looked like
The open messaging means a busy inbox. Most messages I got were ordinary and polite, some were a single “hi”, and a small share were clearly off: profiles with one very polished photo, messages that asked me to move to another messaging app almost straight away, and one that turned to money within a few exchanges. None of it was hard to spot, but it was there, and I had to stay alert.
Blocking and reporting
Every profile and conversation has an option to block or report. Blocking removes the person from your inbox and stops them from contacting you; reporting sends the profile to POF’s team with a reason. I reported two profiles during the test, and both had disappeared when I checked a few days later.
Safety and Security pages
POF’s footer links to Community Guidelines, a Safety page, and a Security page. They cover the basics well: don’t send money, keep conversations on the platform until you trust someone, meet in public, and report anyone who breaks the rules.
My safety tips for POF
- Be wary of profiles with only one photo or very professional-looking pictures.
- Keep the chat on POF until you’ve had a video call; requests to move to another app right away are a common warning sign.
- Never send money, gift cards or financial details, whatever the story.
- Use filters to narrow who appears in your search, and block early when something feels off.
Is Plenty of Fish Legit?
Yes. Plenty of Fish is a long-running dating platform owned by Match Group, with published Terms of Service, a Privacy Policy, Community Guidelines, and apps in both major app stores. During my test, the sign-up, features, and paid plan worked as described.
What people usually mean by “is POF a scam” is whether the platform is full of scammers. In my experience, most members I talked to were ordinary people, but suspicious profiles do get through, and the member reviews below show that many people feel strongly about it. POF is legitimate; staying careful on it is still your job.
Plenty of Fish Customer Service
POF’s support starts in its Help Center, which has articles on accounts, billing, safety, and technical issues. If you can’t find an answer, there’s a contact form; I didn’t find a phone line or live chat. I used the form once, for a billing question about auto-renewal, and got a clear, templated answer by email the next day. It solved my question, but it didn’t feel personal, which matches what many reviewers say.
The POF App vs. the Website

POF is built around its app, available on the App Store and Google Play, and that’s where I spent most of the test. It was fast, notifications arrived on time, and every feature I used was there. The desktop website works for browsing and messaging, but it feels secondary. If you’re choosing one, choose the app.
Plenty of Fish Pros and Cons
What I liked
- You can message people without waiting for a match
- A free account covers the essentials
- Large member base and many ways to browse
- Browsing by interests makes first messages easier
- Fast, complete mobile app
What could be better
- Open messaging means a busy inbox with some spam
- Suspicious profiles still get through
- Support is form-based and slow to feel personal
- Some search results ignore distance settings
- Profiles feel more like forms than personal stories
What Other Members Say
My test is one profile over four weeks, while POF has millions of members and decades of history. So I also read what members say on review sites, Reddit, and Quora. The picture there is much more critical than my own experience, and it’s worth knowing.
Ratings on review sites (as of November 17, 2026)
| Source | Rating | Number of reviews |
|---|---|---|
| Trustpilot | 1.7 / 5 | 52,664 |
| Best Company | 1.7 / 5 | 126 |
“In my experience… POF was a better use of my time. I got more and better quality matches from POF than I ever did from [another app]. One of them became my girlfriend of currently 1.5 years and counting!”
Jeremy Alvarez, Quora
“POF users on average take more time to thoughtfully complete their profile. I found that most users’ profiles told me something about them and their interests that I could use to start a conversation.”
Jeremy Alvarez, Quora
“On the plus side I have made some friends. Had a few dates. Problem is when you say 15 miles from say Phillie and there are tons of guys who are interested in Vermont or Florida.”
Beckie George, Quora
“I have been on and off for about 5 years with this website. Just a few real connections. And now it has gotten worse. There are too many fake profiles.”
★★☆☆☆ Gezim Halilaj, October 5, 2026, Trustpilot
“All i got was scammers… Support was unresponsive.”
Internal_Ad_810, 2026, r/DatingTips
These excerpts are a selection from public review sites, Reddit and Quora, chosen to show both positive and critical feedback. They are individual opinions, may be shortened (marked with “…”), and may not represent every member’s experience. Older Quora answers describe the platform as it was at the time.
Recurring complaints. The most common criticism by far is fake profiles, scammers, and romance scams, followed by the feeling that POF is “no longer free” since paid plans were introduced. Members also mention search results outside their chosen distance, inactive profiles, unwanted or explicit messages, and slow or unresponsive support. Trustpilot notes that POF hasn’t replied to negative reviews there. My own experience was better than this average, which is part of why my score is much higher than the review sites’, but these complaints are consistent and worth taking seriously.
Tips for a Better Start on POF
- Fill in your interests: they decide where you appear when people browse by topic.
- Mention something specific in your first message; it stands out in a busy inbox.
- Set your search filters before you start messaging, not after.
- Try a free account for a week or two before deciding whether the paid plan is worth it for you.
Deleting Your Plenty of Fish Account
If you decide POF isn’t for you, you can delete your account from the settings in the app or on the website. Deleting the account doesn’t cancel a subscription bought through the App Store or Google Play, so cancel that separately in your phone’s subscription settings first. That’s exactly what I did at the end of my test.
Who I’d Recommend Plenty of Fish To
I’d recommend POF to people who like to take the initiative and want plenty of options: you can write to anyone, browse in several ways and do a lot without paying. It suits active daters who are comfortable sorting through a busy inbox and spotting profiles that don’t add up.
It’s probably not the right fit if you want a small, curated inbox, need fast personal support, or would rather not deal with the spam that open messaging brings.
My Final Verdict
Plenty of Fish is still one of the most open dating platforms around: you can message without a match, browse by interests and do most things on a free account, and the app is fast and complete. That openness is also its weakness, because it brings spam and suspicious profiles that you have to filter out yourself, and support won’t hold your hand. If you’re an active dater who stays alert, POF gives you more freedom than most platforms.
Visit Plenty of Fish